Milly Software
Insights›Engagement›Review Stars in Chat Without the 5.0-From-Four-Reviews Problem
Engagement··4 min read

Review Stars in Chat Without the 5.0-From-Four-Reviews Problem

Showing product ratings in your Shopify chat is easy; showing only the ones worth showing takes two thresholds. How Milly Chat's review stars, minimum review count and minimum rating work, and how to pick numbers for your catalogue.

V
Viet Le
co-founder · Milly Software

A product has four reviews, all five stars, left over from a review app you stopped using two years ago. On a product card in your chat, that row reads as your best-reviewed product. It isn't, and a shopper who notices the count stops trusting the rest of the card.

Review stars on product cards help a shopper choose. The useful part is being able to say which ratings are worth showing. Milly Chat gives you two thresholds for that, and the one that catches the problem above isn't the one most people reach for first. Review stars and their thresholds shipped on August 19, 2026.

Turning stars on

Stars are off until you turn them on, in Configure → Product Data under Review stars. Then pick where the ratings come from:

  • Shopify review metafields: Shopify's standard product rating and rating count fields. If your review app publishes ratings into them, this is the simplest option.
  • Yotpo: enter your public Yotpo app key. Stars stay hidden until the key is filled in, since without it there's nothing to fetch.

Ratings are read when your catalogue syncs, not while a shopper is chatting. A slow review service doesn't slow down an answer, and a new review shows up after your next product sync.

The threshold that catches the real problem

The instinct is to set a minimum rating, say 4.5. That doesn't touch the case we started with. A 5.0 average from four reviews passes a 4.5 minimum easily. It passes any minimum rating.

What catches it is Minimum reviews: hide the stars on any product with fewer ratings than this. Four leftover reviews don't clear a minimum of ten, however perfect they are. If you set only one threshold, I'd set this one.

A minimum rating as well

Minimum rating does what it says: hide the stars on a product rated below this, out of 5. Whether to set one is your call. Both thresholds only decide whether the compact chat card shows a star row. They don't change, filter or remove any review: your ratings and reviews stay exactly as they are on your product pages, and the chat card links there. A product has to clear both thresholds to show a rating. Leave either one empty and it doesn't apply.

How the row reads

Two display options, both off by default:

  • The average beside the stars, so the number itself (4.9, say) sits next to them.
  • A word after the count, so "490" becomes "(490 reviews)", or "ratings", or whatever your store calls them. Leave it blank to show the number on its own.

Configure shows a preview of the row as you change these.

No row beats a weak one

A product that fails a threshold shows no rating row at all. Not an empty row of stars, which would look worse than nothing and undo the point of the threshold.

The check happens on our side, before the product reaches the widget. A rating you've hidden isn't sent to the page, so a shopper on an older cached copy of the widget can't see it either.

Picking your numbers

There's no universal right answer, because it depends on how many reviews your products typically collect. A rough way to set it:

  1. Look at a few products whose ratings you'd happily show, and note roughly how many reviews they have.
  2. Look at the ones you wouldn't, often old products or ones carried over from a previous review app.
  3. Set the minimum review count between the two. Add a minimum rating only if there are products you'd rather not advertise by score.

Thresholds are applied when a reply is built, so changing them doesn't need a resync. That makes it cheap to adjust after a week of seeing them on real cards. Review stars and their thresholds shipped in v2.9.13. For more on what the assistant knows about each product, see our post on AI product recommendations.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where does Milly Chat get product ratings from?

Either from Shopify's standard product review metafields (the product rating and rating count fields), or from Yotpo using your public Yotpo app key. You choose the source in Configure → Product Data. Ratings are read when your catalogue syncs, not while a shopper is chatting.

How do I stop a product with only a few reviews showing 5 stars?

Set a minimum number of reviews. A minimum rating doesn't catch this case, because a 5.0 average from four reviews passes any rating threshold. Only a count threshold hides it.

What does a shopper see on a product that fails a threshold?

No rating row at all, rather than an empty row of stars. The threshold is applied on our side before the product reaches the widget.

Try Milly Chat

Want to see how this fits your store?
We'll set up a working session.

Get it on Shopify →Talk to sales →